top of page
Stephanie Kulke

A skillful and unsentimental ‘King Lear’ at American Players Theatre



There is something healing about seeing outdoor Shakespeare. The sounds and sights of trees

swaying, birds calling, and sun setting only heighten the sensory experience of the verse.


There is also the pre-show ritual of picnicking before hiking alongside fellow language lovers to

the On the Hill Theater at American Players Theatre, which makes one feel part of the human

continuum that started when Elizabethans gathered on route to The Globe to eat, drink and

bear-bait.


I couldn’t wait to see APT’s “King Lear” because with lines like “Blow winds, crack your cheeks,”

it is a play that begs to be staged outdoors.


It’s exploration of the chaos and suffering caused by a foolish and tyrannical ruler, however, felt

like a portentous topic to consider in the weeks leading up to a Presidential election.


Mercifully, American Players Theatre’s production offers both food for thought and a welcome

escape from the cares of the present day.

Director Tim Ocel leads his skillful actors through a judicious and cerebral approach to Lear that

refrains from overtly signaling which character’s motives are right or wrong. The effortlessly

performed verse and excitement of following the action-packed play held my interest completely.

Brian Mani makes a virile and Kingly Lear. His resonant voice, silver mane and magnetic gaze

reminded me of a younger, more athletically built Donald Sutherland.

From the top of the play there is momentous action. Lear commands an impromptu court

performance from his daughters to determine Who Gets What Share of the Kingdom. It’s hard to

understand why Lear does this but Shakespeare is less interested in why than in what happens

next.


Lear’s older daughters are hip to the court’s politics and ostentatiously proclaim their devotion.

Goneril (a resplendent presence and cutting performance by Nancy Rodríguez), is married to

the honorable Duke of Albany (Chiké Johnson exudes powerful integrity). Regan (a cold-

blooded and two-faced portrayal by Jessica Ko) is married to the sadistic Duke of Cornwall, (in a

sexy and hot-tempered turn by Ronald Román Meléndez).

Youngest daughter Cordelia (simultaneously wide-eyed and steely as played by Samantha

Newcomb) refuses to flatter Lear with speeches. She states simply that she loves him no more,

no less than is appropriate for their relationship.

Lear hears Cordelia’s response as the ultimate insult to his authority, and his retribution is cruel

and swift. He divides her inheritance between her sisters, retracts her dowry and disowns her.

What motivates Lear’s transactional approach to familial love is not explained but it is certainly a

behavior one recognizes in certain high-profile figures of the present day. But whatever the

cause of Lear’s psychological being, his flawed formula for succession soon rains down

consequences for him and his Kingdom.


He isolates himself further by banishing his advisor Kent (a formidably protective La Shawn

Banks) who fails to goad Lear into retracting his punishment of Cordelia.


Lear’s shock and anger grow as Goneril and Regan reveal his impotence and irrelevance after

his power and wealth have been passed to his heirs.


The companion to Lear’s downfall is The Fool, (vulnerable, playful, and sweet of voice as played

by Josh Krause). Like Kent, he foresaw Goneril’s and Regan’s betrayal, leading to his wistful

line, “Thou shouldst not have been old till thou hadst been wise.”


Ocel’s program notes include a quote from theater director Peter Brook, who says rather than

moralizing, the play is “a vast, complex, coherent poem designed to study the power and the

emptiness of nothing – the positive and negative aspects latent in the zero.”

The power of zero is personified by Edmund (in a swaggering and sinister performance by

Rasell Holt). The bastard son of the Earl of Gloucester, he has nothing to gain in playing by the

rules, so logically he seeks to manipulate those with something to lose, chiefly his brother Edgar

(in a disarming performance by Nathan Barlow), the heir to their father Gloucester.

As Gloucester, James DaVita excels at delivering fresh and surprising line readings. He is a

worthy counterpoint to Lear as another father who lacks the wisdom to see his children for who

they truly are, and has the most violent, darkly comic, and indelible scenes in the play.

I had a few small quibbles. Holly Payne’s eclectic costumes are a nod to the Edwardian era

while also seeming timeless. Goneril and Regan’s dresses and hats are delicious and Lear and


Edgar’s transformations from wealth to beggar are highly effective. However, I found Edgar’s

prep school clothing confusing because it made him appear far younger than Edmund who is

one year his junior.


Oswald the servant served as a whipping post for the dysfunctional royals. I thought it was a

missed opportunity to play him as a crafty opportunist, who like Edmund, is calculating his

allegiances in response to transition in power.

The stage combat is a bit pint-sized. Edmund duels with and tries to halt Cordelia’s execution

with a small dagger instead of a sword. Likewise, brother Edgar fights off Edmund with a

wooden hand mallet.


But these are trivial complaints considering the clarity of storytelling and masterful

performances.


As the furious pace of action ebbs, and the bodies of the poisoned, stabbed, hung and

heartbroken pile up, Edgar expresses the gravity and numbness of the next generation, forced

to face the ruination left by the previous generation.

“We that are young

“Shall never see so much nor live so long.”

Despite the 3-hour run time including one 20-minute intermission – I couldn’t help but wish for a

slightly longer play that included a note of hope and healing at the end.

But after a production that eschews moralizing, there was the consolation of the beautiful

surroundings. And as for hope – it is incumbent on each of us individually to use our wise

judgement to choose a leader that won’t leave the next generation in ruins.


“King Lear” runs through Sept. 28 on The Hill Theatre at American Players Theatre, 5950 Golf

Course Road, Spring Green, Wisconsin. For tickets and more information visit






For more reviews go to https://www.theatreinchicago.com


353 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

773 944 0119 but email at the address above is always preferred.

bottom of page